Permanent recruitment · How to choose · Sydney and NSW
Retained vs contingent vs exclusive recruitment: which should you choose?
Every recruiter sells one of three models. They change who does the work, who carries the risk and how fast you see candidates. Here is each one in plain language, a side-by-side comparison and a five-question fit finder.
- Three models side by side
- Five-question fit finder
- Eight things to ask first
Fees and guarantee periods are agreed in writing before a search starts, so this page does not publish percentages.
The short version
- Contingent. You pay only when you hire the person the agency placed, and you can use other agencies at the same time. Best for urgent or high-volume roles.
- Exclusive. One agency works the role for an agreed period, with a named consultant and a timeline, and you pay on placement. Best when the role is hard to fill but not secret, and you want focus without paying up front.
- Retained. Part of the fee is paid up front for a dedicated search with a shortlist commitment. Best for senior, confidential or hard-to-fill roles.
None is better in general. Each one trades something: speed and breadth for depth, or cost certainty for commitment. The right one depends on the role, the market and what a wrong hire would cost you.
Side by side
| Contingent | Exclusive | Retained | |
|---|---|---|---|
| How you pay | On placement | On placement | Part up front, balance as agreed |
| Who works the role | Any agency you brief, in competition | One agency for an agreed period | One agency, dedicated to the search |
| What you get | Candidates as they are found | A named consultant, a timeline and a priority search | A dedicated search and a shortlist commitment |
| Best for | Urgent or high-volume roles in an active market | Hard-to-fill roles where you want focus without paying up front | Senior, confidential or hard-to-fill roles |
| Main risk | Your role competes with easier ones for the consultant's time, and candidates can arrive twice | If the agency stalls, you lose time, so agree a review point | You pay before the outcome, so agree what each payment buys |
| Ask first | How many other roles is my consultant working? | What happens when the exclusive period ends? | What does each payment stage deliver? |
These are the standard definitions in Australian recruitment,1 and they match how we run each model on our permanent recruitment page. In every model, ask for the replacement guarantee period in writing before the search starts, and agree how earlier introductions are treated if you have already met the person through another route.
Calculator
Which model fits? Five questions
A starting point, not advice. Answer for the role you are about to brief.
Assumptions
| Assumption | Value | Note |
|---|---|---|
| How the finder scores | Scarcity, confidentiality, the cost of a bad hire and flexible timing push toward retained. Hard-but-not-secret roles and a preference for one agency push toward exclusive. Common roles, urgency and wanting several agencies push toward contingent. | Fixed |
What the numbers leave out
- It is a rule of thumb built from how the three models are normally used. It does not know your market, your budget or your internal process.
- Fees and guarantee periods are agreed per search and are not modelled.
What to ask any recruiter before you sign
- What is the fee, when is it due and what does each payment buy? Fees are agreed in writing before the search starts, whatever the model.
- What is the replacement guarantee, and what does it cover? The period, the conditions and what happens if the person leaves.
- Who will actually work the role? A named consultant, and how many other searches they carry.
- How are candidates assessed? A CV screen is not an assessment. For trades and technical roles, ask who tests the skills and whether they have done the job.
- What if we have already met the person? Agree how earlier introductions are treated.
- How often will you report? Set the cadence at the start.
- What happens if the search stalls? For exclusive and retained searches, agree a review point and an exit.
- How is confidentiality handled? Who sees the brief, and when does a candidate learn who you are?
How it works
How a search runs here
The same eight steps in every model. What changes is the commitment around them.
Brief
We learn the site, shift pattern, plant and culture, and agree what good looks like.
Market map
Who is doing this job across Sydney and NSW today, and who could step up into it.
Search and approach
Direct approaches to people already doing the work, candidates we already know and advertising where it helps.
Testing and checks
Trade or technical testing by people who have done the job, then The Smart Standard checks.
Shortlist
A short list with written assessment notes: what we tested, what we saw and where the risks are.
Interviews
We coordinate interviews, brief each candidate and collect feedback from both sides.
Offer and onboarding
We help shape the offer, manage the negotiation and keep the candidate engaged through notice and induction.
Check-ins
We check in after placement with you and the new starter, so small problems surface early.
Questions
Recruitment model questions
What is the difference between retained, contingent and exclusive recruitment?
Contingent: you pay only on placement and can use other agencies. Exclusive: one agency for an agreed period, with a named consultant and a timeline, paid on placement. Retained: part of the fee up front for a dedicated search on senior, confidential or hard-to-fill roles, with a shortlist commitment.
Which model is cheapest?
It depends on the role, so we do not publish percentages. Contingent has no fee unless you hire, which looks cheapest and often is for common roles. Exclusive is priced below retained. Retained costs more but commits the agency. Compare the cost of a bad hire, not just the fee.
Can I switch from contingent to exclusive mid-search?
Often, if you agree the switch point in writing at the start. Ask what happens to fees if a candidate already introduced is hired later, and agree the length of the exclusive period and a review point.
How long does a permanent search take?
It depends on the role and the market. A common trade can move quickly, while a planner, engineer or manager takes longer. We agree a realistic timeline in the brief and update you at set points.
What if the hire does not work out?
The replacement guarantee period is agreed in writing before the search starts. If a placed candidate leaves or is let go within that period, we work with you on a replacement under those terms.
Can you run a confidential search?
Yes. We can search without naming your business, and we handle replacement hires quietly so the person being replaced is not alerted until you decide. Candidates learn who you are once they agree to be put forward.
Do you recruit only trades?
No. We recruit for every role in an industrial business: trades and supervisors, planning and maintenance, operations and plant management, engineering and projects, HSEQ, commercial, finance and admin, sales and executives. See our permanent recruitment page.
Sources and notes
- Sprintlaw: How do recruitment agencies work in Australia?. General Australian explanation of contingent, retained and exclusive models. Used for definitions only. No figures are taken from it. Accessed 3 October 2026.
Ready when you are
Brief the role. We will recommend the model.
Tell us the role, the site and the timing. We agree the model, the fee and the guarantee in writing before the search starts.